INTRODUCTION
Dairy calves are typically removed from their mother soon after birth and artificially reared either individually or in group housing. The practice of early cow-calf separation has become a source of public concern associated with the removal natural behaviors of nursing and suckling [
1]. Research examining cow-calf rearing has focused on indoor housing systems [
2] with a paucity of data available for pasture-based cow-calf systems with no data available on milk production, calf development, and behavior. Pasture-based systems present new challenges including cows required to walk long distances to the milking parlor and rotational grazing of paddocks which involve daily, sometimes hourly shifts. There are additional concerns regarding calf exposure to the weather, practicality of labor, and practicality of implementation of pasture-based cow-calf systems [
3].
Many dairies offer calves a restricted diet of 4 to 6 L milk/d [
4] allocated in 2 feeds, but some farms have adopted ‘accelerated’ feeding programs offering greater than 8 L milk/d [
5]. Greater quantities of milk increase weight gain [
6,
7] however, greater milk consumption can decrease solid feed consumption [
7] and has been argued to be linked to reduced rumen development [
8]. Cow-calf contact systems allow calves access to relatively high volumes of milk, and calves kept with the cow typically show greater rates of body weight (BW) gain, higher milk yields in first lactation [
9], but the effects on cow milk production are unclear [
10].
Although previous work has assessed the impact of per manent cow-calf separation on cow and calf distress responses [
10], cow-calf rearing systems also require periods of temporary separation, for example when cows go to the milking parlor. Research on temporary separation is limited and has focused on motivation and reuniting cows and calves instead of the process of separation. Thus, there is need for work investigating the impact of short-term separation given cows are milked on average twice daily and the potential for a smooth transition to permanent seperation. The objectives of our work were to determine the impact of a pasture-based cow-calf rearing system across an extended duration of 100 days on i) cow milk production, ii) calf BW gains and carcass quality, and iii) cow and calf behavior during separation for milking.
DISCUSSION
Calves spent almost half of their time in close proximity to their mother in the first week of life, but this declined rapidly as calves aged. Due to the limited work conducted over the long-term on dairy cow-calf systems (particularly those reared on pasture), extrapolation from cow and calf behavior in beef systems is used here for comparison. Greater distances between beef cows and their calves have been reported as calves aged [
14]. In the study by Vitale et al [
14], cows and calves were observed for 70 d postpartum, with calves spending the majority of time more than 15 m from their mother. In our study, calf independence increased with calf age, as indicated by the greater distance between calves and their mother and the decrease in suckling bouts. Suckling is a bonding as well as a nutritive behavior [
15]. The calves in the current study decreased suckling frequency by 5% from wks 1 to 12, corresponding with increased consumption of other feeds. Similar reductions in the duration and number of bouts of suckling have been observed for pasture-reared beef calves from 1 to 6 mo of age [
15], and for intensively reared dairy calves maintained on the cow for 8 weeks [
16].
Grazing became more frequent as calves aged, increasing by 17% from wk 1 to 12. Work undertaken about 6 decades ago reported that male dairy calves reared on pasture without access to the cow began grazing at about three weeks of age [
17]. The lack of more recent data suggests the need for future work evaluating cow and calf grazing behavior. Our findings are consistent with previous work reporting an increase in grazing when calves [
18] were introduced to pasture with mature cows, suggesting that less experienced cattle may learn from older animals. Thus, rearing calves together with the mother may provide some learning and behavioral advantages to develop grazing behaviors at a younger age.
The cow-calf system in this experiment involved twice daily separation of cows from calves for milking, due to the impracticality of managing calves in the milking parlor. Most research describing the behavior of cows and calves at separation is limited to acute behaviors indicative of distress (mainly vocalizations and seeking behaviors) and investigating long-term behavioral effects in calves (e.g. abnormal and social behaviors) [
10]. Cows and calves vocalize in response to separation distress [
19]. The low frequency of this behavior in this experiment (average percentage of time vocalizing: 3% across the study) suggests that calves (and cows) quickly habituated to the routine. Similarly, the 5-fold reduction in attempts by the cows to return to their calves in the early stage of the experiment when compared to the mid and late stages, and the low probability of this behavior in the mid and late stages (2%) also suggests that cows habituated to temporary separation during milking. More work is needed to assess the intensity and duration of distress responses to temporary separation in cows and calves.
Cow vocalizations and attempts to return to their calf on the way to milking during the temporary separation process may provide some insight into the acute stress associated with temporary separation [
19,
20]. These responses declined rapidly as cows habituated to the system, however multiparous cows were used in the study, and it is unknown how first lactation heifers may respond. To our knowledge, this is the first experiment to describe vocalizations during rearing of calves and cows kept on pasture. The results are in line with the low number of vocalizations recorded during the first few hours after full separation in previous early separation studies in indoor housed systems [
21,
22]. The period of separation for milking (approximately 2 h) is similar to the first few hours of full separation despite our cows being habituated to the routine of temporary separation. Thus, the initial cow response to this short period of separation within the first few weeks of the experiment is comparable to the response within the first few hours of full calf separation. However, the longevity of the study allowed for habituation to temporary separation resulting in the decrease in stress response.
Attempts by the cows to return to the paddock while walk ing to the milking parlor reduced by 25% between week 1 and week 10 of the experiment. Similarly, although anecdotal, Grøndahl et al [
23] stated that they observed little to no distress in response to temporary separation for milking when cows were kept with their calves in an intensive system for 6 to 8 wks; however, more work using larger sample sizes is needed to substantiate this claim. Incrementally enrolling cows into a cow-calf contact system might aid in habituating new cows to the system, as new members learn the routine through the habituated cows. The use of a grain reward when exiting the paddock may also assist the training process and can be removed once the cows have habituated to the system. Overall, our findings indicate that short term separation to allow for milking can be achieved, in the context of this experiment, and provides evidence that cows are able to habituate to the routine of this system.
Our results highlight the potential to achieve high levels of calf growth when they are offered unrestricted access to their mother, in addition to concentrate and pasture or hay in a pasture-based system. The elevated BW gains of these calves was likely due in large part to a high quantity of milk consumed, though actual milk consumption was unable to be measured. Based on the increase in cow milk yields after separation, we estimated calf milk intake at approximately 19 L/d in the final week of the study (about 15 wk of age) and corresponds to approximately 10% of their BW at this time which is the recommended milk consumption for dairy calves [
6,
7,
24]. We were unable include a comparison group of non-nursing calves of a similar age and sex due to logistical constraints on farm, however these consumption estimations are greater (although comparable) than the 12 L/d at 9 wk reported by de Passillé et al [
2], and the 15 L/d at 13 wk reported by Roth et al [
25] where calves had
ad libitum access to suckle from their mother. Our experiment consisted of only male calves which have been reported to drink 16 L/d at 6 wk of age [
26] providing reasonable explanation for the 19 L/d at 15 wk. These results suggest that milk consumption of Holstein calves reared with their mother continues to increase about 1 L/wk from 9 to 15 wk after birth. However, calves allocated
ad libitum milk replacer allowance was less than our calves with reported consumption between 8 L/d and 12 L/d [
7,
27]. According to Asheim et al [
9], comparisons to
ad libitum milk allowances using automatic milk feeders is difficult as calves may drink more while suckling from cows. However, increased milk consumption linked to higher milk yields in first lactation [
9] suggest a pay off when these replacement heifers begin lactating.
Calf BW gains averaged 1.4 kg/d, more than double the industry standard of 0.6 kg/d for conventionally reared Australian heifer calves [
24] and calves fed lower volumes of milk either individually or in groups (4 L/d of milk from wk 1 to 7; then 2 L/d, 0.68 kg/d [
28]; 4L/d, 0.81 kg/d [
29]). The gains we reported are double those of Holstein-Friesian calves reared conventionally which is expected given the restricted milk intake of conventionally reared calves compared to
ad-libitum access to milk in the current study. Daily BW gains in our study were also higher than those reported for calves on greater than conventional milk allocations (6 L/d, 0.58 kg/d; 8 L/d, 0.57 kg/d; 10 L/d, 0.65 kg/d; and 12 L/d, 0.88 kg/d; [
7]; 4 L/d of milk from wk 1 to 7, then 2 L/d, 0.68 kg/d; [
28]; 8L/d, 0.86 kg/d; [
29]) and calves fed
ad libitum milk from artificial teats (0.82 kg/d, 6; 0.81 kg/d, [
30]). The calf weight gains in the current study were more comparable to those of beef calves reared with cows on pasture, with ADG ranging from 1.3 to 1.5 kg/d [
31]. The use of only male calves in this study may have resulted in an exaggerated impact on growth as male calves have been reported to gain more weight than heifer calves [
32]. These results suggest that providing calves with the opportunity to obtain milk directly from the cow is beneficial. Although calves had
ad libitum access to grain-based concentrate, the amount consumed was negligible (<1 kg/calf/d) suggesting weight gain was impacted more from other sources of feed. The calves may have benefited from access to the fresh pasture, especially the high protein of the upper stratum of the pasture sward [
33], however further work is required to disentangle these effects.
Pasture consumption has previously been associated with yellow fat color in meat [
34–
36]. However, the mean fat color from calves reared on the cow in the current experiment was white which is more favorable from a meat grading perspective [
34,
36]. The white fat color was likely due to the young age of the calves at slaughter, where the degree of yellow fat color increases with age [
34], and that a large portion of calves’ energy intake came from milk rather than grass. Interestingly, calf meat in the current study was scored as a bright cherry red color, contrasting previous studies reporting a pale red for veal arising from calves fed milk and grain-based concentrate (127 d-old calves; [
35]), but aligned with the findings of Muir et al [
37] that pasture reared cattle have meat of darker color. The 100-day-old calves in this study also produced similar carcass yields (59%) as 127-day-old milk-fed calves (56%; [
35]). Overall, this work demonstrates the potential to achieve favorable carcasses with white fat and red meat from a pasture-based cow-calf system, though replication with larger sample sizes would be necessary to understand this effect on a commercial scale.
In addition to measuring carcass characteristics, the stom achs of each calf were dissected and weighed. The calves had a smaller proportion of reticulorumen, and a greater proportion of abomasum, as compared to 12 to 16-wk-old conventionally reared calves, with the reticulorumen and abomasum averaging 67% and 15% respectively of the stomach weight [
38]. High milk intakes can reduce grain intake and slow rumen development [
39]. However, despite consuming large volumes of milk the calves in the current experiment had heavier reticulorumens (2.1 kg) than those reported for 8-wk-old (0.93 and 1.0 kg; [
30]), 9-wk-old (conventional: 1.6 kg; [
8]), 10 wk old (starter without hay: 1.59 kg; starter with hay: 1.89 kg; [
40]), and 12-wk old calves (1.9 kg; [
41]). Reticulorumen weights in the current study were similar to values reported previously for 9-wk-old calves weaned in a milk step-down program (STEP: 2.2 kg; [
8]) and 14-wk-old calves reared conventionally (2.3 kg; [
42]) while expectantly weighing less than 20-wk-old calves (2.5 kg; [
43]). In addition, abomasum tissue from the calves weighed more (0.9 kg) than the industry average 9-wk-old (0.57 kg and 0.71 kg; [
8]), 10-wk old calves (starter without hay: 0.48 kg; starter with hay: 0.47 kg: [
40]), 12-wk-old calves (0.7 kg; [
41]), 14-wk-old [0.5 kg; [
42]) and 20-wk-old calves (0.5kg; [
43]). It should be noted that all the calves in the reviewed studies were reared on restricted milk feeding programs, in contrast to
ad libitum access to milk in the current study. Ellingsen et al [
44] also found that the abomasum of calves offered high milk volumes (6 L per feeding) were more distended and larger than those fed restricted levels of milk (2 L per feeding). A distended abomasum is expected to be accompanied by slower rumen development, but this was not observed in the study perhaps associated with access to fresh pasture and the age at slaughter. Despite negligible starter pellet consumption, rumen development was on par with recommendations suggesting the need to re-evaluate the recommendations on grain calf starter in pasture-based dairy systems.
This study only evaluated 6 cow-calf pairs, which limits the conclusions of the study and extrapolation to a commercial level while providing direction for future research. The sample size provided the ability for a large data set and longitudinal data while also limited due to practicality and farm requirements. However, recent scrutiny against management of male dairy calves has encouraged farmers to grow out their male calves which gives dairy farms the opportunity to capitalize on meat market [
45]. Future research using heifer calves can evaluate impact on longitudinal effects of this system through to lactation. Further research should include a treatment group of non-suckling cows and calves to allow for comparison of the impact of long-term calf suckling on production outcomes. Currently, there is an abundance of literature cow-calf separation in indoor housed systems, however there are clear gaps in knowledge as to the impacts of temporary separation and long-term behavioral responses of cows and calves when maintained together. The next probable comparison is beef cattle as they are maintained in similar environments (long-term cow-calf system on pasture) and natural cow-calf behavior has been consistent [
46]. The use of historic research further identifies areas needing further research.