In situ ruminal DM and CP degradability of feed ingredients for experimental TMR diet
The
in situ ruminal DM degradability of the feed ingredients used in the experimental TMR diets for this
in vivo trial is shown in
Figure 1. For accurate comparison, the SB used in this
in situ measurement and
in vivo trial was the same feed ingredient prior to heat treatment of HSB. At 0 h of incubation, the degradability of raw SB and wheat bran exceeded 30%, while that of HSB was 25.14% (p<0.05). Lee et al [
20] also reported that the DM degradability of soybean meal at 0 h was more than 30% and Pan et al [
21] reported that the degradability of wheat bran at 0 h was close to 50%. The degradability of corn flake increased continuously from 19.05% at 0 h to 80.42% at 48 h. The degradability of SB slightly rose from 41.47% at 4 h to 46.51% at 16 h, then exponentially increased to 92.03% at 24 h. Conversely, the degradability of HSB gradually increased to 31.67% at 4 h, 32.84% at 8 h, 45.17% at 16 h, 61.31% at 24 h, and 79.24% at 48 h, significantly lower than the 96.92% at 48 h for raw SB (p<0.05). The DM degradability of wheat bran linearly increased to 43.12% at 48 h from 10.65% at 0 h. The final DM degradability (72 h) for corn flake, SB, HSB, wheat bran, and rice straw were 89.15%, 98.99%, 85.36%, 80.13%, and 49.82%, respectively. Assuming an outflow rate of 4% (
Table 4), the ED was the highest for SB (70.98%), followed by wheat bran (63.53%), corn flake (56.95%), HSB (53.26%), and rice straw (29.60%) (p<0.05).
The
in situ ruminal CP degradability of the feed ingredients is presented in
Figure 2. The CP degradability of corn flake at 0 h was 17.25%, showing continuous increase to 74.16% at 72 h. The raw SB for the degradability at 0 h was 16.32%, exponentially increase to 77.05% at 16 h and continuously increase to 96.63% at 72 h. Maxin et al [
22] reported CP degradability of SB at 0 and 16 h was 23% and 78%, respectively. Compared to this study, the degradability at 0 h was higher, but the degradability at 16 h was similar. The degradability of HSB at 0 h (12.36%) was lower compared to raw SB (p< 0.05), with gradual increases to 47.48% at 48 h. Therefore, considering that the retention time of SB in the rumen is less than 48 h and mostly degraded within 24 h [
20], the 48 h of degradability was 45% units lower than raw SB. The ruminal CP degradability of both initial and final times for wheat bran were the highest among the feed ingredients in this
in situ experiment (p<0.05), reaching 34.67% and 97.31%, respectively. Pan et al [
21] reported that the CP degradability of wheat bran was more than 30% at 0 h and 83% at 16 h. Compared to this study, the degradability at 0 h was similar, but the degradability at 16 h (71.41%) was approximately 12% unit different. After 24 h, both studies showed the degradability of over 90%. The CP degradability for rice straw was from 1.38% at 0 h to 68.56% at 72 h.
The RUP (% of CP) values were highest for HSB (70.03%), followed by corn flake (58.49%), rice straw (55.79%), SB (33.44%), and wheat bran (27.41%). However, considering the CP content of each feed ingredient, the actual contribution of true RUP (% of DM) to the total diet was 37.10% for HSB, 17.57% for SB, 4.70% for corn flake, 4.42% for wheat bran, and 2.23% for rice straw, thus the proportion of corn flake, wheat bran and rice straw being significantly lower than those of SB and HSB. The NRC Beef Cattle [
3] model estimated RUP for corn flake, SB, and wheat bran as 70%, 29%, and 36%, respectively, while the NRC Dairy Cattle [
23] estimated them as 69%, 63%, and 18%, respectively. This difference is due to the fact that NRC Beef Cattle [
3] presented RUP values for feed ingredients calculated by uniformly applying a 5% outflow rate (
kp) using the fraction system (A, B, C,
kd) to the
in situ rumen CP degradability. Contrarily, in the NRC Dairy Cattle [
23], the fraction system was maintained but the outflow rate for each feedstuff was calculated to derive the values. The calculation of
in situ CP degradability in this experiment was based on NRC Beef Cattle [
3], showing similar values. In addition, data on RUP for rice straw were scarce, and the protein content of rice straw is considered to have a minimal effect on performance.
Modified three-step in vitro protein digestibility of feed ingredients
The
in vitro digestibility of RUP in the small intestine for the feed ingredients is presented in
Table 5. The IDP (% of RUP) for corn flake, SB, and HSB were 92.72%, 94.35%, and 96.61% respectively, indicating similar values. The IDP of wheat bran was 71.91%, which was lower than those of corn flake, SB, and HSB but higher than that of rice straw (52.31%) (p<0.05).
The IADP (% of CP) was the highest for HSB (67.65%), followed by corn flake (54.23%), soybean meal (31.55%), rice straw (29.19%), and wheat bran (19.71%) in descending order (p<0.05). Considering the CP content of each feed ingredient, the actual contribution of the true IADP (% of DM) to the total diet for corn flake, SB, HSB, wheat bran, and rice straw was 4.4%, 16.6%, 35.8%, 3.2%, and 1.2%, respectively. Thus, the difference between SB (16.6%) and HSB (35.8%) was approximately 19% units.
The TDP (% of CP) was the highest for SB (98.11), showing a slightly lower value for corn flake (95.74%) (p<0.05). However, HSB (97.62%) showed a similar value to SB, which is attributed to its low RDP but increased IADP after heat treatment. Therefore, HSB is considered as an appropriate feed ingredient to increase CP content when considering RUP. Wheat bran (92.30) showed lower values compared to corn flake, SB, and HSB but was higher than rice straw (73.40%) (p<0.05).
Several studies [
24,
25] estimating IDP for protein sources using the same also reported high digestibility over 97% for SB. According to the NRC [
23], the IADP for corn flake, SB, and wheat bran were 90%, 93%, and 69%, respectively, being similar to the results of this experiment. Meanwhile, when formulating the actual feed formula, it is important to consider not only the RDP and RUP ratios but also the intestinal digestibility of each feed ingredient.
Animal performance
During the whole experimental period (16 weeks), the average, minimum, and maximum values of ambient temperature, relative humidity, and THI on every 4 weeks are presented in
Table 3. From the 1st to the 4th period, the average temperature, humidity, and THI sequentially decreased as the period progressed (p<0.05). Average temperature, humidity, and THI during the hottest 1st period were 29.1°C, 72.3%, and 82.9, respectively, which correspond to moderate (THI 82 to 84) level of heat stress according to the THI chart for fattening Hanwoo steers based on NIAS [
4]. In the 2nd period, these were 26.9°C, 62.5%, and 76.9, respectively, indicating mild (THI 76 to 81) heat stress level. The 3rd period following the hot period (1st and 2nd period), had average temperature, humidity, and THI of 23.5°C, 65.3%, and 70.9, respectively, and the 4th period had 19.8°C, 67.9%, and 65.8, with both periods experiencing conditions under comfort (THI below 75) level.
The BW, DMI, ADG, and FCR of fattening Hanwoo steers measured every 4 weeks from the initial to the end of the experiment for control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB are presented in
Table 6. The initial weights for the control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB were 479.1, 492.6, 482.5, and 485.0 kg respectively, showing no significant difference between treatments. The final weights for control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB were 589.2, 617.6, 615.5, and 624.6 kg respectively, showing weight gains of 110.1, 125.0, 133.0, and 139.6 kg for each treatment, respectively.
According to the NIAS [
4], to prevent sudden decreases or refusal of feed intake during the late-fattening period, the amount of recommended daily TMR diet per an early-fattening Hanwoo steer is 10.5 kg (DM basis), which was adhered to in this experiment through restricted feeding. No significant difference in DMI was observed among treatments during the whole experimental period. However, during the 1st period, the DMI for control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB was 6.97, 6.99, 6.95, and 6.95 kg/d, respectively, which decreased by 34% compared to the recommended daily TMR intake (10.5 kg/d; DM basis). Previous research on feeding additional TDN and CP to Hanwoo steers during the late-fattening period reported a similar reduction of 33% in DMI at severe conditions (THI above 87.0). Thus, despite being the moderate level in this study, a similar reduction in DMI was observed as in the severe conditions. This could be due to the narrow range of moderate (THI 82 to 84) level, potentially exposing the animals to severe conditions [
6] and the relatively higher roughage ratio in the TMR during the early-fattening period compared to the late-fattening (25% vs 12%, respectively), leading to higher heat production from ruminal microbial fermentation and consequently reduced feed intake to mitigate the heat [
26]. Similar to the results observed in the chamber study with early-fattening Hanwoo steers by Woo et al [
6], it was interpreted that in Severe conditions, the DMI of forage was lower than that of formula feed, which was closely related to heat production in the rumen. During the 2nd period, with Mild level (THI 76.9), the DMI was 8.78, 8.86, 8.86, and 8.83 kg/d for control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB, respectively, which is 19% lower than the recommended daily TMR intake. As the temperature moved to Comfort level in the 3rd period, DMI increased to 9.98, 9.99, 10.00, and 9.98 kg/d, respectively, and in the 4th period, it reached 10.02 kg/d across all treatments, indicating nearly complete recovery of feed intake.
During the hottest 1st period, the ADG for Control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB was 0.57, 0.68, 0.70, and 0.79 kg/d, respectively (p<0.05). Thus, PF+SB+HSB, the treatment with TDN and CP levels increased by 10% each considering RUP, showed a 39% improvement in ADG compared to control (p<0.05). No difference was observed between PF and PF+ SB, and these two treatments showed intermediates between control and PF+SB+HSB. The ADG during the 2nd period was higher for PF+SB (1.16 kg/d) and PF+SB+HSB (1.14) compared to control (0.95) (p<0.05). In the 3rd period, PF+ SB+HSB (1.51 kg/d) showed no significant difference from PF+SB (1.43) but was approximately 10% higher than PF (1.37) and 24% higher than control (1.22) (p<0.05). The 4th period showed a similar trend to the 3rd period, and control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+HSB were 1.19, 1.33, 1.42, and 1.48 kg/d, respectively. Overall, the ADG improved during the 1st and 2nd period for treatments with protein supplementation, especially noticeable in the treatment with HSB. Moreover, during the recovery period (3rd and 4th period) after the hot season, treatments with HSB showed improved ADG compared to both control and PF. The ADG during the whole experimental period increased significantly in the order of PF+SB+HSB (1.23), PF+SB (1.18), PF (1.11), control (0.98 kg/d) (p<0.05), suggesting the cumulative effects of the entire feeding experiment over 16 weeks were expressed.
A study by Kang et al [
27] showed no significant difference in ADG, probably due to the low level of energy increase when PF was used to increase the TDN by 3% in growing Hanwoo steers. Another study on energy levels by Jo et al [
7] conducted an experiment with Hanwoo calves under comfort (THI 70 to 73) or severe (THI 89 to 91) conditions in a controlled temperature and humidity chamber, fixing the CP at 17.5% and tested the TDN levels of 70%, 73%, and 75% using corn (2×3 factorial arrangement). This study reported a difference in ADG between Comfort and Severe, but no difference between TDN levels under the same heat stress conditions. These results suggested that energy additions of less than 5% do not influence ADG. On the other hand, a protein level study by Kim et al [
17] fixed the TDN at 73% in the diet of Hanwoo calves and used SB to conduct CP levels of 12.5%, 15%, and 17.5% (3×3 factorial) with 3 THI levels in a controlled temperature and humidity chamber. This study reported that improvement in ADG was observed with increasing level of CP as heat stress increased from mild (THI 70 to 73) to moderate (THI 74 to 76) and to severe (THI 89 to 91).
The above studies in Hanwoo [
7,
17,
27] have investigated the effects of increasing either energy or protein levels under heat stress conditions. Previous research [
9] demonstrated that while treatments increasing TDN levels by 10% showed a positive impact on ADG in late-fattening Hanwoo steers during the hot season, treatments that increased CP levels by 10% without considering RUP did not show a clear difference compared to other treatments. This might be due to excess ammonia production in the rumen from the simple addition of SB to increase CP levels, leading to urea excretion [
4]. In conclusion, compared to the ADG of Control during the whole period, PF improved by 13%, PF+SB by 20%, and PF+SB+HSB by 26%, although the absolute differences were not large.
During the 1st and 2nd period, the FCR improved in PF+SB+HSB compared to control (p<0.05). In the 3rd and 4th period, the FCR among control, PF, PF+SB, and PF+SB+ HSB showed similar changes in ADG (p<0.05). During the whole period, the FCR sequentially decreased for control (9.10), PF (8.09), PF+SB (7.61), PF+SB+HSB (7.27) (p<0.05). Therefore, this study showed that feeding TMR diets with an increased TDN level using PF and CP level considering RUP by 10% each during the early-fattening period of Hanwoo steers can prevent the decline in performance under heat stress and positively affect performance recovery after the hot season.
Physiological parameters
The results from increasing TDN and CP levels by 10% each using PF, SB, and HSB in Hanwoo steers during the early-fattening period under heat stress on physiological parameters are presented in
Table 7 and
Figure 3. During the whole period, there was no significant difference in all physiological parameters among treatments. However, when comparing each period, average RT for the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period were 39.33°C, 39.30°C, 38.99°C, 38.76°C, and 38.70°C, respectively, showing differences, albeit not large, with high significance (p<0.001). Therefore, the RT during Moderate of 0 and 1st period was the highest, followed by the 2nd period (mild) being higher than the 3rd and 4th period (comfort) (p<0.05;
Figure 2). In addition, the RT of 3rd period was higher than that of 4th period (p<0.05). An increase in RT in ruminants indicates an increase in endogenous heat production [
28]. According to Woo et al [
6], the RT of Hanwoo steers during early-fattening period in a chamber with controlled temperature and humidity was reported as 37.39°C, 37.80°C, 38.65°C, and 39.20°C for comfort (THI 73 to 75), mild (THI 77 to 79), moderate (THI 82 to 84), and severe (THI 85 to 86) levels, respectively (p<0.05). Moreover, previous research [
9] showed that the average RT under ambient temperature conditions for Hanwoo steers in the late-fattening period increased in the order of 4th (comfort; 38.48°C), 3rd (comfort; 38.46°C), 2nd (moderate; 38.76°C), 1st (severe; 38.85°C), and 0 period (severe; 38.95°C) (p<0.05). These findings support the observation that the extent of heat stress during the 1st period in this experiment was similar to severe level, leading to a similar decrease in DMI.
When compared among periods, average serum cortisol concentrations were 9.95, 9.54, 8.94, 6.56, and 6.31 ng/mL for the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period, respectively (p<0.001). Serum cortisol concentrations were the highest during the moderate stage of 0 and 1st period and were higher in the 2nd (mild) than in the 3rd and 4th period (comfort) (p<0.05;
Figure 2). Similar to the results of this study, previous research [
9] found cortisol concentrations of 8.86, 8.44, 8.41, 7.07, and 7.07 ng/mL for the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period, respectively, with significant differences over time. When comparing the results of this study with previous research [
9], the concentrations were higher than Severe even though the heat stress was at moderate. Similar to RT, these physiological parameters probably influenced DMI. Another study [
29] observed an increase in cortisol concentrations of Hanwoo steers during early-fattening period under ambient conditions to at THI 80 to 87 (9.87 ng/mL) compared to 1.91 and 5.13 ng/mL at THI 64 to 71 and THI 72 to 79, respectively. However, this study suggested that cortisol concentrations could exceed 9.5 ng/mL at THI 82.9 in Moderate conditions. The increase in cortisol concentrations in ruminants under heat stress is due to adrenal cortex secretion in response to heat stress [
30]. Hence, changes in RT and serum cortisol concentrations indicate that animals of this feeding trial undergo heat stress during the 1st and 2nd period.
Average serum glucose concentrations for the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period were 71.60, 75.72, 81.87, 83.49, and 85.51 mg/dL, respectively (p<0.001), with the lowest concentration during the 0 period and increasing through the 1st, 2nd, and 4th period (p<0.05;
Figure 2). However, the 3rd period was not significantly different from either the 2nd or 4th period. Previous research [
6] also reported a decrease in serum glucose with increasing THI. The primary reasons for this result were changes in glucose production due to decreased feed intake and increased insulin concentration in the body [
8]. Furthermore, PF may not have a direct effect on serum glucose concentrations because they do not interfere with rumen fermentation processes and can be absorbed by the small intestine to provide more energy for the ruminant [
9,
31].
Average serum NEFA concentrations for the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period were 261.0, 239.5, 238.2, 172.8, and 158.6 μEq/L, respectively (p<0.001), with the highest concentration during the 0 period (p<0.05;
Figure 2). Several studies [
6,
7,
9,
17] have reported a decrease in blood glucose and an increase in NEFA concentrations under heat stress. The increase in NEFA concentration due to decreased blood glucose is related to subcutaneous lipid breakdown, acting as an alternative energy source [
32].
Average serum BUN concentrations the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period were 18.52, 18.51, 16.92, 16.92, and 16.10 mg/dL for, respectively (p<0.001), with the highest concentrations during the 0 and 1st period and higher concentrations in the 2nd and 3rd period compared to the 4th period (p< 0.05;
Figure 2). Similar to the previous research [
9], concentrations of BUN were not changed by nutritional differences among treatments. However, BUN concentrations were higher during severe (THI 87.0) and moderate (THI 82.8) levels compared to comfort levels (THI 71.4 and 68.1). This could be due to increased blood BUN during heat stress, resulting from inefficient incorporation of ruminal ammonia into microbial protein or deamination of amino acids mobilized from skeletal muscle in the liver [
8]. Secondly, heat stress may lead to inefficient metabolism of rumen protein and amino acid imbalance, reducing the absorptive function of the rumen epithelium and leading to an accumulation of BUN in the blood [
33].
Average serum GOT concentrations for the 0, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th period were 86.12, 86.08, 77.96, 76.71, and 76.70 U/L, respectively (p<0.001), with higher concentrations during the 0 and 1st period compared to the rest of periods (p<0.05;
Figure 2). Serum GOT concentration is a marker for liver cell damage and can indicate the extent of liver function impairment due to heat stress [
8]. According to NIAS [
4], serum GOT concentrations during severe (THI 85 and above), moderate (THI 82 to 84), and mild (THI 82 to 84) levels of heat stress were reported as 85 and above, 79 to 85, and 75 to 78 U/L, respectively. The GOT concentrations of this study were indicative of severe levels suggested by NIAS [
4]. In conclusion, physiological indicators such as RT, serum cortisol, glucose, NEFA, BUN, and GOT concentrations did not vary among treatments based on TDN and CP levels in the diets but showed significant differences over period (p<0.001), making them appropriate parameters for determining whether Hanwoo steers have experienced heat stress. In addition, these results imply that the stages of the Hanwoo THI chart presented by NIAS [
4] are well differentiated.
Animal behaviors
Animal behavioral measurements with hot and post-hot season in early-fattening Hanwoo steers fed a 10% increase in TDN and CP levels are presented in
Table 8. The primary aim of measuring animal behaviors was not to focus on behavioral changes due to variations in nutritional levels across treatments but to compare changes in behaviors under heat stress conditions. No significant differences were observed in any behavioral measurement due to differences in diets among treatments. Consequently, significant changes in behaviors between the 1st (moderate; July) and 3rd (comfort; September) period were identified.
Lying decreased by approximately 24% in the 1st period compared to the 3rd, while total standing increased by 50% (p<0.05). Additionally, walking decreased by 48% in the 1st period compared to the 3rd (p<0.05). Previous research [
9] also found that Lying decreased by 43% from comfort (THI 71) to severe (THI 87), total standing increased by 48%, and walking decreased by 62%. Another study [
29] reported that lying in Hanwoo steers during the early-fattening period decreased by 25% from comfort (THI 64 to 71) to severe (THI 80 to 87), while standing increased by 11%. It is known that ruminants try to minimize contact with the ground and maximize body surface area to reduce body temperature under heat stress [
3].
Eating decreased by 40% in the 1st period compared to the 3rd, while drinking increased by 43% (p<0.05). This was interpreted as a result of a 30% decrease in DMI during the 1st period compared to the 3rd period. Previous research [
9] also reported a decrease in DMI by 36% from comfort to severe, resulting in a decrease in eating by 38% and an increase in drinking by 54%. The decrease in eating time and increase in drinking time are attributed to sweating and panting to regulate body temperature under heat stress. This respiratory and thermoregulatory water loss can lead to an increase in water intake, which in turn may also influence the decrease in DMI [
3].
Rumination during standing increased by 38% in the 1st period compared to the 3rd, while Rumination during lying decreased by 32% (p<0.05). This was because lying decreased by 24%, and total standing increased by 50%. Previous research [
9] showed that rumination during standing increased by 53% from comfort to severe, while rumination during lying decreased by 33%. Total rumination time was relatively lower during the hot season compared to the post-hot season, primarily due to the effect of decreased feed intake under heat stress, leading to reduced rumen motility and increased retention time of feeds in the rumen [
8]. Therefore, changes in rumination during standing and rumination during lying during the hot season of this experiment were considered as appropriate indicators for assessing the degree of heat stress in ruminants. Furthermore, although the extent of changes in behavioral measurements varied between this study and the previous research [
9] due to differences in experimental conditions (level of heat stress, weight, age, feed intake, forage-to-concentrate ratio), the trends in changes were similar.