DISCUSSION
National Research Council nutrient requirement estimates are considered as the minimum requirements for pigs. In practice, trace minerals are generally supplemented at NRC requirement estimates or greater without considering the indigenous trace minerals in the feedstuffs. Because of this, the actual concentrations of trace minerals in the diet are generally greater than the requirement estimate of trace minerals. In the current study, dietary trace mineral analysis indicated that the concentrations of Cu, Fe, and Mn in the basal diets without trace mineral premix were adequate to meet the NRC [
8] requirement estimate for pig growth. The Mn concentration in the basal diet exceeded the requirement estimate by at least 3-fold and only the concentration of Zn in the basal diet was generally deficient across all dietary phases. After removing the trace mineral premix in Phase V, the indigenous Mn and Fe concentrations were still greater than the actual requirements estimates while Cu was marginal and Zn was potentially deficient in comparison to the NRC [
8] nutrient requirement estimate. Therefore, the deletion diet in Phase V may actually have been only a Zn-deficient diet.
In the current study, the source of trace minerals had no impact on absolute or relative organ weights during the growing and developing periods, with the exception of relative liver weight. This is in agreement with Gheisari et al [
11] who suggested that organic chelates of Zn, Mn, and Cu had no effects on the absolute and relative weights of spleen and liver in birds. A similar result was observed by Peters et al [
12], where sow liver weights were not affected by the source of trace minerals (organic vs inorganic) and the level of trace mineral supplementation over six parities. However, in the current study, the relative weight of the liver from pigs fed ITM diets tended to be heavier than those fed OTM diets. In agreement, Martin et al [
13] evaluated OTM vs ITM supplementation in starter pigs and demonstrated that pigs fed ITM providing 100% of the NRC [
8] requirement estimates had greater liver weight when expressed as percentage of BW than pigs fed the OTM diets. Martin et al [
13] stated the effect of this greater liver weight in pigs fed inorganic trace minerals is unknown. The liver is known as the major tissue for trace mineral storage and body homeostasis. Trace minerals in liver are stored in different protein-binding complexes. The current study showed that more Fe from the ITM treatment was deposited in the liver than from the OTM treatment; therefore, the differences of trace mineral content or concentration and corresponding protein-binding complex in the liver from the different sources may contribute to the relative liver weight difference.
Shelton et al [
6,
14] reported that removing the trace mineral premix (Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, I, and Se) in pigs during the whole growing and finishing period resulted in an increase in liver weight of pigs, but phytase reversed the response; other tissues (e.g., kidney) were not affected; in another study, Shelton et al [
15] reported a decreased liver weight in growing pigs fed diets with phytase. However, Deyhim and Teeter [
16] reported that the liver and spleen weights and the relative weights of the same tissues were not affected when chicks were fed diets without trace minerals (Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, I, and Se) from 28 to 49 days. In the current study, heart, liver, kidney, and spleen weights were not affected by the trace mineral deletion. The different results from that of Shelton et al [
6,
14] may be related to fewer days of removal of the trace mineral premix from the diet in the current experiment or to the fact that I and Se remained in the deletion diet in the current study.
For all minerals, changes in the tissue content and concen tration varied by tissue. There were no patterns that were distinct for all tissues. The lack of patterns may be related to mineral form but also to the relative priority of different tissues.
In the current study, the different sources of trace mineral pre mix were supplemented in the diet beginning at weaning until 80 kg BW, which was a period of about 98 d. Heart Mn concentration has been used to measure the bioavailability of Mn in sheep because the response best fit a linear model when dietary Mn was added at 500 to 4,000 mg/kg [
1]. In the current study, heart Mn content or concentration responded positively to the organic source of Mn as did other tissues consistently. However, Li et al [
17], in a study with chicks, indicated that heart Mn content or concentration failed to show the difference among the sources of Mn, including Mn methionine complexes, Mn proteinates, and Mn amino acids. Another possibility for the different response is potential interactions between Mn and other trace minerals. Manganese is believed to share the same transporter (i.e., divalent metal transporter) with Cu and Fe and previous evidence has also shown that supplementing pig diets with Zn reduced Mn absorption and retention [
6,
18]. In the current study, four trace minerals, namely Cu, Fe, Mn, and Zn, were supplemented as an organic form and the uptake mechanism is believed to be different from metal transporters, such that the interactions between Mn and other trace minerals might be eliminated or reduced. A tissue increase was evidenced not only in heart Mn, but also kidney, liver, and muscle Mn were elevated from the organic source. However, the mechanism behind those results needs to be further investigated.
With regard to Fe, Yu et al [
19] demonstrated that organic Fe (an iron amino acid complex) increased the total Fe concentration in liver, spleen, and muscle (ham) more than ferrous sulfate. However, in the current study, tissue Fe from the different sources of Fe showed differences in liver and LD muscle but inconsistently between the two tissues. Organic Fe deposited more Fe in muscle but inorganic Fe deposited more Fe in liver. Iron is known to be stored in liver as ferritin and hemosiderin. Iron in muscle, on the other hand, is stored mainly as myoglobin (heme Fe). However, the stored Fe only accounts for 1/3 of total Fe in the body, the remaining 2/3 Fe is in the circulation, the majority as hemoglobin (heme Fe) in blood [
2]. Liver Fe status is generally believed to reflect the animal’s Fe status. In a recent sow study, Peters et al [
12] fed OTM (Bioplex Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn; Alltech Inc., USA) to reproducing sows across 6 parities and demonstrated that the liver Fe was not affected by the source of trace minerals (OTM vs ITM: 133.9 vs 144.6 mg/kg; p = 0.39). Even though the result was not significant, the similar trend, where inorganic trace mineral deposition was greater than organic trace mineral deposition, was shown in the current study. In agreement, Martin et al [
13] evaluated the OTM and ITM supplementation from weaning to 35 d postweaning and demonstrated that iron sulfate deposited more Fe in liver than organic (chelated) source of Fe but not in kidney. A recent trial conducted by Thomaz et al [
20] indicated that iron sulfate fed pigs have more liver Fe than Fe proteinate fed pigs for an inclusion rate at 100% of requirement but similar liver Fe at 50% requirements for nursery (postweaning to 42 d) pigs. In an early study by Standish and Ammerman [
21], excess Fe as ferrous sulfate or ferric citrate fed to sheep increased liver and spleen Fe dramatically, but the muscle Fe was not affected. However, the current finding indicated the muscle Fe can be changed with organic sources of Fe and there may not be adequate Fe for liver from the organic source. This is consistent with the suggestion that the organic source of Fe is absorbed via alternative pathways, possibly amino acid or peptide transporters, and stored in different tissues.
Copper, after being absorbed in the intestine, rapidly enters blood circulation and is quickly deposited mainly into the liver [
22]. Transcuprein is involved in the initial distribution of incoming dietary Cu to liver and kidney [
23]. The trace mineral concentration in kidney typically increases with higher dietary mineral intakes. In the current study, organic Cu deposited more Cu in LD muscle and in kidney than inorganic Cu but the liver Cu was similar between the two treatments. Guo et al [
24], in a chick study, reported that Cu proteinates deposited more Cu in liver compared with Cu sulfate and Hansen et al [
25] reported that feeding copper glycinates in calves resulted in greater liver Cu, but those two studies did not report other tissue Cu concentrations. However, Miles et al [
26] in chicks and Mondal et al [
27] in kids failed to show any sustained advantage for organic Cu in liver. In a rat study, Rojas et al [
28] reported that muscle and kidney Cu concentrations from copper sulfate were higher than copper lysine. In another study, Engle et al [
29] failed to detect the effect of organic Cu (proteinates) on liver and
longissimus muscle Cu concentration in growing and finishing steers. There are inconsistent results from a variety of sources of Cu. In the current study, the organic Cu did elevate Cu in LD muscle and kidney. High Cu in kidney, which is also an excretory route for many minerals may indicate that the organic Cu provides more available Cu than the pigs need; as a result, animals have to excrete them instead.
Organic Zn has received much attention in pig research. In the current study, only metacarpal bone Zn was elevated by the organic source of Zn. Kidney Zn showed some tendency to increase with organic Zn. In agreement, Cheng et al [
30] reported zinc lysine and ZnSO
4 have equal effects on liver and kidney Zn concentrations in young pigs. A similar result reported by van Heugten et al [
31] demonstrated piglets fed basal diets with an addition of 80 ppm Zn from zinc methionine and zinc lysine did not affect Zn concentrations in liver, pancreas, and spleen. In another pig study, Case and Carlson [
32] supplemented 500 ppm Zn as a Zn-amino acid complex or ZnO in piglets and showed a similar Zn concentration in liver and kidney. A recent study done by Thomaz et al [
20] reported that Zn proteinate resulted in similar metacarpal bone Zn content compared with ZnSO
4, but both treatments were greater than control (no Zn supplementation) for postweaning to 42 d trial. Clearly, bone Zn was elevated with Zn supplementation but there was no source difference. But in the current trial, bone Zn was elevated with organic Zn, the disparity might be due to the duration of the trial (42 d vs 98 d) or level of supplementation. The current result might indicate that the NRC [
8] level of Zn is adequate for normal animal growth.
Tissue mineral concentration may be one of the indicators of mineral metabolism in the body and to some extent, might be one of the measurements of the mineral bioavailability. Generally, the current results indicate that the organic source of the trace minerals Cu, Fe, Mn, and Zn might have higher bioavailability based on greater mineral being deposition into the various tissues, especially for Mn and Cu. The exception may be that the current study showed that the organic Fe had a negative impact on liver Fe concentration. Research needs to be conducted on more indicators (e.g., plasma Fe status or hemoglobin status) to give the full picture of Fe status in the body.
In the current study, the trace mineral premix (Cu, Fe, Mn, and Zn) was removed from the study prior to slaughter for 6, 4, 2, and 0 (no removal) weeks. The results did show trace mineral status in the various tissues was changed with the duration of trace mineral deletion. One remarkable response was evidenced by the change of Mn concentration during the deletion period. In almost all the collected tissues (heart, kidney, liver, and LD muscle), Mn concentrations increased with increasing duration of trace mineral deletion. Kidney Fe showed a similar trend as Mn in visceral tissues. As expected, Zn concentrations in kidney, liver, spleen, and metacarpal bone decreased as the time of trace mineral deletion increased as did kidney Cu.
Shelton et al [
6] removed the trace mineral premix (Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, I, and Se) in growing and finishing pigs (22 to 109 kg) and demonstrated that liver Zn content or concentration was decreased whereas Mn was increased; liver Fe and Cu content or concentration were not affected by the trace mineral removal; metacarpal bone Zn was decreased as well as muscle Zn tended to be decreased by the trace mineral premix removal, which agrees with the present results of Zn status in liver, muscle, and bone. In addition, Adeola et al [
18] indicated that supplementing pig diets with Zn decreased Mg and Mn absorption and retention, which indicated that there might be an interaction between Zn and Mn. In the current study, even though Mn and Zn concentrations in heart, spleen, and LD muscle were not shown as consistent as liver and kidney, Mn and Zn concentrations in those tissues of ITM-fed pigs clearly provided evidence of the interaction between Mn and Zn. However, Shelton et al [
14] in a nursery pig study, and Shelton and Southern [
33] in a chick study, did not observe the Zn×Mn interaction, which indicates that the degree of this interaction may differ in different physiological stages and among species.
In the current study, liver and LD muscle Cu and Fe content or concentration were not affected by the trace mineral deletion, which is consistent with Edmonds and Arentson [
4], Shaw et al [
5], and Shelton et al [
6]. However, the current research did observe that kidney Cu content or concentration was decreased and Fe content or concentration tended to be increased with increasing duration of trace mineral deletion. The decreasing kidney Cu content or concentration was probably due to the decreasing dietary Cu level. No explanation is made for a kidney Fe increase with decreasing dietary Fe level.
Metacarpal bone mineral content has often been assessed for Ca and P, but less so for trace minerals. In the current trial, with increasing duration of mineral deletion, almost all of the trace minerals analyzed in bone were decreased, especially for Zn. In agreement, Thomaz et al [
20] reported that metacarpal bone Zn was elevated dramatically with mineral supplementation compared with control (no mineral supplementation) during a 42-d nursery pig study. Interestingly, bone Cu and Mn were decreased with additional mineral supplementation, which may suggest a certain level of mineral-mineral interactions. In addition, Shelton et al [
6] reported that bone Zn and Mn were decreased when mineral premix was removed from the grow-finish diets, but for Cu and Fe there was no consistent effect on the mineral content in bone.
Interactions between the source and the duration of trace mineral deletion were observed in the current study. With increasing time of trace mineral deletion, organic Zn deposited more in LD muscle whereas inorganic Zn deposited less in muscle. A similar observation occurred in spleen Mn content or concentration, namely, ITM deletion caused spleen Mn content or concentration to increase, but, in the OTM treatment, spleen Mn content or concentration remained constant during the deletion, indicating that animals can mobilize body reserve Mn to compensate for the lower Mn level in the diet.