INTRODUCTION
Fusarium mycotoxins produced by different fungal species are common contaminants of food and feed ingredients. According to Shephard et al [
1], 25% of the worldwide crop production is contaminated with mycotoxins. Mycotoxin ingestion is considered a severe health problem for both humans and animals. High concentrations of mycotoxins in feed cause major adverse effects; although in a number of cases, mycotoxin levels are too low to produce immediate clinical symptoms. Chronic-level exposure of farm animals to mycotoxins generally results in reduced growth rate, reproductive problems, and increased incidences of different non-infectious and infectious diseases, the latter mostly due to repression of the immune function [
2]
Fusarium mycotoxins are a root cause of substantial economic losses in animal husbandry. Moreover, severe health problems, including severe gastrointestinal tract diseases and malignant tumors, have been reported in both animals and humans, due to long-term exposure to mycotoxins in the diet [
3].
Deoxynivalenol (DON) and zearalenone (ZEN) are the most common
Fusarium mycotoxins, which are commonly spreading contaminants in animal feed, mostly cereals and forages. These two mycotoxins are characteristically constant under varying environmental conditions and have been identified to cause a diversity of toxic effects in humans, farm animals, and experimental animals. Pigs are more sensitive to DON and ZEN exposure than most other species, partly because of species-specific differences in the metabolism of DON and ZEN [
2].
DON can cause toxic effects in a variety of cell systems and various animal species, causing changes in immune cell function, dysregulation of the humoral immune response, and reduced host resistance toward pathogens [
4]. DON is also the reason for cytotoxicity to fibroblasts, reticulocytes, and lymphocytes. DON inhibits cell division rate, and RNA and DNA synthesis by binding to ribosomes [
5]. At low exposure concentrations, DON upregulates the expression of cytokines and inflammation-related genes, with simultaneous immune stimulation; however, at high exposure, it causes leucocyte apoptosis together with immune suppression [
6].
ZEN exhibits strong estrogenic and anabolic activities, causing significant changes in the reproductive system of domestic and laboratory animals [
7]. This results from the capacity of ZEN to bind to the estrogen receptors, leading to hyperestrogenism in various animal species, particularly pigs [
8]. Once it enters the body, it is primarily metabolized in the liver, which appears to be one of the major targets of this toxin [
9]. ZEN also shows many genotoxic and cytotoxic problems
in vitro or
ex vivo, and is potentially carcinogenic [
10]. ZEN is also known to be immunotoxic; however, its function in the inflammatory response is not yet fully understood. ZEN functions as both inductor and suppressor of inflammatory cytokine production [
2].
According to the previous research reports of the DON and ZEN effects on pigs; in the present study we are using higher toxic levels of 8 mg DON/kg and 0.8 mg ZEN/kg feed, respectively, for 4 weeks treatment. To the best of our knowledge, there is no RNA-transcriptome studies were focused on DON and ZEN treated pigs kidney samples. Therefore, in the present study, we perform an RNA-transcriptome analysis for the profiling of gene expression patterns in the kidney samples of control, DON, and ZEN dietary pigs. The RNA-transcriptome analysis would help gain insights into the effects of mycotoxins on the immune- and metabolism-related genes. Identification of the gene expression patterns of various biological processes is significant to understanding the effect of DON and ZEN ingestion. In addition, potential marker genes and affected pathways should be identified and examined to obtain a better understanding of how chronic levels of DON and ZEN-polluted feed affect the kidney function in pigs.
DISCUSSION
The contamination of animal feed with DON and ZEN is a universal problem, given the capacity of the fungus that synthesizes DON and ZEN to grow in any environmental condition [
2]. DON and ZEN contamination of food and feed has been frequently linked with substantial effects on human and animal health. To date, very little is known about the effects of DON and ZEN on the transcriptional levels in farm animals. Therefore, we used an RNA-seq approach to assess the effects of DON and ZEN on the universal transcriptome expression in the kidneys of pigs fed DON- and ZEN-contaminated diets for 28 days. The analysis and inference of RNA-seq data depends largely on the ultimate goal of the study, which, in this case, was to examine differential gene expression. The RNA-seq data illustrated a wide range of expression levels in the kidney samples, which are stable and reliable in the DON and ZEN dietary treatments. Detection of genes and pathways altered by dietary
Fusarium toxins might lead to improved diagnostic, treatment, and prevention strategies for mycotoxicosis.
The RNA-seq data for DON and ZEN showed genes that had an altered profile compared with the control group. Of these genes, 107 were upregulated and 79 were downregulated. Some of the significant up- and downregulated genes and their roles are listed in
Table 2. In this study, both mycotoxins were found to affect the immune system, cell proliferation, and cytokine networks. Here, we elucidate some of these significantly affected up- and downregulated genes. However, comparable studies in pigs are not available for each gene, which are needed for further analysis of the obtained results. The RNA-seq screening revealed a significant number of up- and downregulated genes. Increased gene expression was observed in
KIF20A (FC: 2.11),
CYP1A1 (FC: 2.01),
IgH (FC: 8.43),
HIST1H2BC (FC: 2.10), and
STMN1 (FC: 2.23).
KIF20A is a protein-coding gene, which is necessary for the chromosome passenger complex-mediated cytokinesis. The GO annotations for this gene are connected to protein kinase binding and ATPase activity, and it is also associated with immune system pathways and vesicle-mediated transport [
15]. The
CYP1A1 protein is a monooxygenase; it catalyzes a variety of structurally unrelated compounds such as xenobiotics, and is involved in drug metabolism. This gene is associated with the diseases Ehrlich tumor carcinoma and lung squamous cell carcinoma [
16]. IgH is the large polypeptide subunit of an antibody. It recognizes foreign antigens and initiates immune responses such as phagocytosis and induces the complement system. IgH is linked with follicular lymphoma 1 and mantle cell lymphoma, in addition to the immune response mediated by DAP12 receptors in NK cells and immune response Fc epsilon RI [
17]. Similar to our results, Butler and Wertz [
18] also found that
IgH gene expression in piglets is related to the immune response toward various stress conditions.
HIST1H2BC is a protein-coding gene, which plays a major role in antifungal, antibacterial, and antimicrobial activities. Tollin et al [
19] found that this gene participates in human colonic defense against microbes and fungi. The
STMN1 gene is a phosphoprotein that regulates several important cellular functions. The increased expression of
STMN1 has been observed in many human cancers and confers a poor prediction. According to Cheng et al [
20], the upregulation of
STMN1 is seen in primary nasopharyngeal carcinoma, and its expression has been linked with the recurrence and advanced stages of the disease. Many groups have demonstrated that the inhibition of this gene might partly reverse the malignant phenotype.
Using the RNA-seq data, we also recognized some of the significantly downregulated genes associated with inflammatory response, cell proliferation, and cytokine networks. The expression of
IL10RB (FC: −2.10) was downregulated. It is an important anti-inflammatory marker of cytokine signaling gene and is encoded by the cytokine receptor family. It is an accessory chain, necessary for the active interleukin 10 receptor complex. Co-expression of
IL10RB gene has been shown to be essential for IL10-induced signal transduction. Diseases linked with
IL10RB comprise inflammatory bowel disease, and autosomal recessive and early-onset colitis.
IL10RB is associated with the immune system pathways and Jak/STAT signaling pathway [
21]. Similar to our results, a significant downregulation of
IL10 was observed in the liver samples of ZEN-fed pigs [
22]. Downregulated
CXCL9 and
CXCL10 genes (FC: −3.27 and FC: −2.37, respectively) encode small cytokines related to the CXC chemokine family. These two genes have many functions, including chemoattraction for monocytes, NK cells, and T cells, promotion of T cell adhesion to endothelial cells, antitumor activity, and inhibition of bone marrow colony formation and angiogenesis [
23].
CXCL9 and
CXCL10 are associated with pathways involving G protein-coupled receptor and peptide ligand-binding receptors. According to Altara et al [
24],
CXCL9 and
CXCL10 are suitable biomarkers for the development of heart failure and left ventricular dysfunction in humans.
CCL4 (FC: −2.14) is also a chemokine protein, which is a chemoattractant for natural killer cells, monocytes, and a variety of other immune cells; it gets secreted and has chemokinetic and inflammatory functions. CCL4 is associated with human immunodeficiency virus 1 and meningitis; it is linked with the immune system and toll-like receptor signaling pathways. Johannes et al [
25] reported that
CCL4 modulates cell death and survival and immunological and hematological diseases, in various animals fed DON- and ZEN-contaminated feed. In the present study, we found that the lysozyme (
LYZ) enzyme was significantly downregulated (FC: −2.43); it is an antimicrobial enzyme produced by animals, and is found in the spleen, kidney, plasma, and other tissues. LYZ is mainly involved in the innate immune system, and is associated with amyloidosis and familial visceral diseases. It is related to the immune system and salivary secretion pathways.
Insulin like growth factor binding protein 4 (
IGFBP4; FC: −2.03) is a unique gene, which frequently inhibits numerous cancer cells
in vivo and
in vitro. Its inhibitory action has been exhibited
in vivo in prostate and colon cancer. IGFBP4 protein is secreted by most of the colon cancer cells. This gene is linked with the diseases involving insulin-like growth factor and renal osteodystrophy, and is associated with the pathways of β-catenin-dependent Wnt signaling and myometrial relaxation. According to Shen and Singh [
26],
IGFBP4 gene expression plays a significant function in the transition from proliferation to separation of a human colon cancer cell line, CaCo
2. Wan et al [
27] revealed that due to trichothecene toxicity,
IGFBP4, an insulin-like growth factor (
IGF)-binding protein, was suppressed in the rat pituitary adenoma gretchen hagen 3 (
GH3) cells, demonstrating that the T-2 toxin gave rise to a growth hormone-
IGFBP4 deficiency in the cells. In the present study, the
C4BPA gene (FC: −2.10) was downregulated. It is involved in the complement system, acting as an inhibitor. C4BPA binds to apoptotic and necrotic cells, and DNA, facilitating clean up after an injury. A number of fungal and bacterial pathogens bind to the human
C4BPA, which permits them to establish infection. C4BPA is associated with protein S deficiency and acute post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis, and is involved in the immune system and pertussis pathways [
28]. PTPRC (FC: −2.09) belongs to the protein tyrosine phosphatase (
PTP) family. It is a signaling molecule that regulates different cellular processes such as cell growth, mitotic cycle, differentiation, and oncogenic transformation. This gene is an essential regulator of T- and B-cell antigen receptor signaling. It suppresses JAK kinases, and therefore, functions as a regulator of cytokine receptor signaling. Alternatively spliced transcript variants of
PTPRC, which encode distinct isoforms, have been reported. This gene is linked with severe combined immunodeficiency, B-cell/natural killer cell, T cell-negative and positive selection, and hepatitis C virus [
29]. The most significant immune response gene
IgH (FC: −10.09) was highly downregulated. It is associated with antigen receptors expressed by B cells and secreted by plasma cells, and is one of the major components of the adaptive immune response. IgH also acts as a cell-surface receptor for antigens, which permits cell signaling and cell activation, and for soluble effector molecules, which can individually bind and neutralize antigens at a distance. The IgA, IgM, and IgG concentrations were significantly decreased in the peripheral blood lymphocytes of the piglets that were fed contaminated feed with various
Fusarium mycotoxins [
30]. Based on these results, we hypothesized that, in our present study, the toxic levels of DON and ZEN might affect the immune system, and we found that IgH was highly suppressed. The
OAS2 gene (FC: −2.72) is a member of the 2–5A synthetase family, and this gene is mainly involved in the innate immune response to viral infection. OAS2 might also play a role in other cellular processes such as cell growth, differentiation, apoptosis, and gene regulation. It is also associated with the immune system and interferon gamma signaling pathways. Similar to our results,
OAS2 gene expression was also suppressed in the lung tissue of mice orally gavaged with DON [
31]. In the present study, the
ANGPTL4 gene (FC: −2.20) showed downregulation. This gene is associated with hypoxia-induced expression in endothelial cells. It can control angiogenesis and modulate tumorigenesis. ANGPTL4 reduces proliferation, migration, and tubule development of endothelial cells, and decreases vascular leakage. It might also serve a protective function in endothelial cells through endocrine action. It is directly involved in regulating glucose homeostasis, insulin sensitivity, and lipid metabolism, and is associated with severe non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy [
32]. Downregulation of
ANGPTL4 has also been associated with type 2 diabetes.
Apart from the above-mentioned genes, most of the DEGs mentioned in
Table 2. are also associated with the immune response, and inflammatory and proliferation networks. We predict that higher toxic levels of DON and ZEN lead to significant decreases in the gene expression of inflammatory cytokines, and are also connected with a decrease in the level of other inflammatory mediator genes. The expression profiles of DEGs in DON and ZEN treatments showed that most genes were downregulated than upregulated. Due to acute toxicity levels of DON and ZEN, a number of inflammatory and proliferation-associated genes were downregulated, and it was observed that some of the upregulated genes were associated with various diseases. The functional annotation analysis also illustrated more GO biological process terms and KEGG pathways related to immune system, metabolic processes, and diseases in both DON and ZEN treatment groups (
Tables 1,
2,
3).
In KEGG enrichment analysis, we identified significant immune- and disease-associated pathways (
Table 3,
Supplementary Figure S4). We found some pathways associated with human diseases, and concluded that there might be consequences of DON and ZEN toxicity in humans. Remarkably, almost all genes found in the present study were downregulated. We hypothesized that severe toxic levels of DON and ZEN could modulate and downregulate various genes that inhibit the activation, apoptosis of immune cells. In this study, the most important inflammatory response-related cytokine-cytokine receptor interaction pathway was identified and chemokine genes
CCL4,
CXCL9, and
CXCL10, and the anti-inflammatory gene
IL10RB were found to be downregulated. Cytokines and their specific receptors represent a system that plays a major role in blood and immune cells. Cytokines are vital intercellular regulators and mobilizers of cells engaged in innate as well as adaptive inflammatory host defenses, cell growth, cell death, differentiation, angiogenesis, and development and repair procedures aimed at restoration of homeostasis. According to Amuzie et al [
33], DON induces the expression of suppressors of cytokine signaling in mice, and has the potential to play a regulatory role in signaling pathways mediated by the cytokine receptor superfamily members such as
GH and inter leukin-6 (
IL-6) that eventually affect inflammation and growth, respectively. Suppressor of cytokine signaling -induced negative regulation of cytokine and growth factor pathways has been confirmed in several
in vivo and
in vitro studies involving a number of species [
34]. Metabolic pathways might be involved in different diseases; in this study, metabolic pathways were associated with
ALDH7A1, carboxylesterase 1,
CYP1A1, and
CYP2B22, all of which were downregulated. These genes are associated with various diseases and immune inhibition. The metabolism of most mycotoxins in humans and animals remains unclear. Observed metabolic pathways of trichothecenes, including DON, ZEN, T-2 toxin, 3-aDON, nivalenol, diacetoxy scirpenol, and fusarenon-X in humans, swine, poultry, and ruminants [
35]. Toll-like receptor (TLR) signaling pathways regulate the downregulation of
CCL4,
CXCL9, and
CXCL10 genes. TLR signaling pathways can play a major role in the activation of the adaptive immune system by inducing pro-inflammatory cytokines and upregulating costimulatory molecules of antigen-presenting cells. Activating the TLRs leads to the sensitive expression of different inflammatory genes, which have a protective role against infection. TLRs in renal cells are implicated in innate immune responses in kidney infection. According to Gu et al [
36], TLR stimulates DON-exposed intestinal porcine epithelial cells, which could alleviate the reduction in cell survival and proliferation of immune cells.
In the present study, the important inflammatory immune response of chemokine signaling pathway was observed to be significantly expressed. This is a part of the normal immune system function, as chemokines are important components of basal leukocyte trafficking necessary for immune system functioning and development, and immune surveillance. Chemokines also contribute to the growth, differentiation, and activation of leukocytes, and motivates diverse effector functions. Similar to our results, previous studies have reported that the chemokine genes were downregulated in the spleen and intestinal samples of ZEN- and DON-treated piglets, respectively [
37]. In this study, the chemokine genes
CXCL9,
CXCL10, and
CCL4 might be suppressed due to severely toxic levels of DON and ZEN.
We also found some significant disease-related pathways in the present study. However, the role of DON and ZEN on these pathways is not yet fully known. The SLE pathway involves
HIST1H2BC and
IgH. It is a prototypic autoimmune disease characterized by the creation of IgG autoantibodies and it is particular for self-antigens. Hueza et al [
38] showed that ZEN-treated animals showed autoimmune disorders such as SLE. We also found the chemical carcinogenesis pathway, and it is expected that exposure to environmental chemical carcinogens might be responsible for a majority of human and animal cancers. Genotoxic carcinogens such as DON and ZEN can attack biological macromolecules such as RNA and DNA, directly or indirectly, during metabolism, resulting in the formation of adducts with these macromolecules [
39]. We also found tuberculosis and Epstein-Barr virus infection pathways, both of which are related to
IL10RB and
IgH. The immune response of
IL10RB and
IgH genes was downregulated. IgH and
THBS4, associated with the phagosome and phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase-Akt (PI3K-Akt) signaling pathways, were also found to be downregulated. Phagocytosis is the process of taking in comparatively large particles by a cell, and is an essential mechanism in tissue remodeling, inflammation, and protection against infectious agents. According to Food Research Institute, DON inhibits phagocytosis, and consequently, causes immunosuppressive effects. PI3K-Akt signaling pathway is stimulated by several types of cellular stimuli or toxic exposures, and controls primary cellular roles, including transcription, translation, growth, and proliferation. It is mainly involved in a broad range of biological processes, such as apoptosis and intestinal inflammation, and the intestinal barrier. Zhang et al [
40] revealed that PI3K/Akt pathway was altered due to DON-mediated intestinal toxicity in porcine epithelial cells exposed to 20 μM DON for 60 min.
A number of studies suggest that DON and ZEN are powerful immune modulators, acting as immunosuppressive as well as immune-stimulatory agents [
6]. This is strongly supported in our present study. For instance, as discussed earlier, most of the immune-related DEGs and pathway associated gene expression profiles were altered (suppressed or upregulated) due to severely toxic levels of DON and ZEN. A majority of
in vivo studies have focused on a broad array of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines that are noticeable in various organs such as liver, spleen, kidney, and lung, after DON and ZEN exposure [
37]. The kidney might play the primary role in the inflammatory response along with the growth of acquired immunity. DON and ZEN stimulate apoptosis, dysfunction, inflammatory response, and oxidative stress in mouse kidney [
41]; however, very little data are available on the
in vivo effects of DON and ZEN on the modulation of kidney inflammatory markers in pigs. Our study demonstrated that a number of significantly affected genes following the exposure to DON- and ZEN-contaminated diet treatments were associated with inflammatory response. Our inflammatory gene expression profile is somewhat similar to those identified using microarray analysis in spleen samples of ZEN-fed pigs [
37]. In the present study, we found a significant downregulation of
IL10RB,
CXCL9,
CXCL10,
CCL4, and some other genes (
Table 2), which are some of the most powerful inflammatory markers. Stoeker et al [
42] revealed that the expression of these genes might entail a risk of making the inflammatory response worse, with lesion formation at tissue stage. Similarly, Pistol et al [
22] also investigated the changes in pig liver, which showed a significant reduction in inflammatory cytokine gene expression, as a result of ZEN contamination. The mRNA expression of cytokines was downregulated in the jejunum of DON-treated (0.9 mg/kg feed) piglets, and in the ileum of piglets after chronic exposure to low-level DON [
43]. We also observed that DON and ZEN exert their effects on the expression of several genes through communication with transcription and signaling factors. These toxins might cause renal failure due to immunosuppression, which might have significant consequences during an infectious process.
A maximum tolerable daily intake for ZEA of 0.5 μg/kg of body weight is now recognized by the Joint Committee WHO/FAO, based on the no observed-effect level of 40 μg/kg body weight/d found in a 15 day study in pigs. The committee suggested that the total intake for ZEA and its metabolites should not more than this concentration [
44]. Prepuberal gilts fed diets polluted with ZEA (0.004 to 0.358 mg/kg) exhibited hepatocyte glycogen depletion and expansion of hepatic interlobular connective tissue and hemossiderosis in spleen [
45]. In earlier studies, concentrations of DON and ZEN from 1 to 150 μM were used alone or in combinations to examine their cooperative or antagonistic effects on inhibition of macromolecular synthesis, DNA methylation and fragmentation. Moreover, the above concentrations are in accordance with the levels possibly encountered in the gastrointestinal tract of human or animals tissues after utilization of food or feed polluted with 2 to 4 mg/kg of body weight of DON and ZEN [
46]. Six pro-inflammatory cytokines of
IL1α,
IL1β,
IL6,
IL8,
TNFα, and monocyte chemotactic genes were up-regulated in the porcine jejunal epithelial cell line in reaction to individual and mixtures of cytotoxic concentrations at DON 2 μM, and ZEN 40 μM treatments. All these pro-inflammatory cytokine shows a significant role in initiation of the inflammatory response in the intestinal epithelial cells [
47]. According to Pistol et al [
22], 316 parts per billion ZEN contaminated diet reason for desperately reduced the gene expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as
TNF-α,
IL-1β,
IL-8,
IL-6, and interferon-γ in the liver of piglets fed the ZEN contaminated diet. Also observed, DON induced modest expressions of pro-inflammatory genes such as
TNF-α,
IL-1β, and
IL-6 in the liver relative to the spleen of mice [
48]. The mRNA expression of cyclooxygenase-1,
IL-1β,
IL-10, and
TLR4 levels were decreased in the jejunum of piglets fed a DON (0.9 mg/kg feed) diet when compared to a control diet [
49].
Taken together, our results demonstrated that DON- and ZEN-contaminated diets induce significant alterations in the global transcriptome levels in pig kidneys. A total of 186 genes with a significantly changed profile compared with the control diet group were found through RNA-seq analyses; among these, 64% genes were upregulated and 36% downregulated. Pathway analysis pointed out that DON- and ZEN-affected genes are associated with various diseases and infections. It was also observed that the expression of most of the DEGs involved in inflammatory response was suppressed by DON and ZEN. Based on these results, we postulate that DON and ZEN might have an biphasic effect in vivo, via the suppression of inflammatory response in pigs or any other animal kidneys, which might affect immune homeostasis. This is not only of relevance for a further risk characterization of DON and ZEN exposure in growing pigs and other farm animals, but might also serve as a model for studies trying to estimate interference strategies to alleviate adverse health effects of DON and ZEN.